Wednesday, June 7, 2023

Where to get pies in Toledo for Pi Day 2022

Happy Pie Day! Yes, it’s actually “Pi Day,” but let’s be honest: Would you rather spend the day celebrating a mathematics pun, or celebrating with a delicious slice of locally-made dessert? Yeah, that’s what we thought. Here are a few of the best places in Toledo for pie!

See something we missed? Let us know at!

Al Smith’s Place
3550 Executive Pkwy, Ste. 12. 419-531-0600.
Grab a slice of fruit pie for $3.99, or one of Al’s specialty pies for $4.25.

Bakery Unlimited
4427 Secor Rd.
6620 W. Sylvania Ave., Ste. 3C.
The talented artisans at Bakery Unlimited offer Boston cream pie, cherry pie and apple pie every day for $12.99 each.

Earth to Oven Cafe
5758 Main St., Sylvania. 419-824-0683.
Offering full pies catered, including large fruit pies for $16 and deep dish seasonal pies for $18.

34 Huron St. 419-241-6728.
5629 Main St., Sylvania. 419-517-4448.
121 S Main St., Bowling Green. 419-205-9021.
Stop by Grumpy’s and finish your meal with their pie or cake slice of the day for $7.

Ideal Hotdog
1135 W. Alexis Rd. 419-478-3023.
4330 Heatherdowns Blvd. 419-382-7686.
Finish your lunch with a slice of Ideal’s freshly made pies for $1.85.

Jera’s Heavenly Sweet
3059 W. Bancroft St. 419-214-1107.
Jera’s offers a mouth-watering variety of pies in 3 sizes: 6” mini pies for $7.50, 9” regular pies for $14 or 10” large pies for $20.

J’mae’s Home Cooking
3312 Glendale Ave. 419-720-8222.
J’mae’s dessert offerings vary by day, but if you can get your fork into their pecan or sweet potato pie, consider yourself lucky.

MacQueen Orchards
7605 Garden Road, Holland. 419-865-2916.
MacQueen’s Bakery and Sweet Shop offers 24 different flavors of pie, including apple, peach, cream and berry pies in season.

Michael’s Cafe and Bakery
101 Main St. 419-698-2988.
Despite the name, cheesecakes are really custard pies, so you can have it on Pi Day and be totally in fashion. Get cheesepie for $4.50 a slice or $40 for a whole pie at Michael’s.

2103 N. Reynolds Rd. 419-535-9116.
A dizzying array of pies, all made on site, make Schmucker’s one of the area’s favorite pie destinations. Order pies in advance or stop in for a slice ($3.59 and up) or a whole pie ($15 and up).

Strachn Bakery
759 S. Holland Sylvania Rd. 419-867-8297.
Offering a variety of pies (apple cherry, peach, chocolate and many more) in both 6” and 10” varieties, Strachn’s also features delicious seasonal pies.

Tiger Bakery & Deli
4215 Monroe St. 419-473-8942.
6710 W. Central Ave. 419-842-0047.
Looking for something savory? Tiger offers a variety of fatayer— individual pies in a variety of flavors, from cheese to meat pies.

Related Articles